Galapagos Syndrome
Friends and family
Home markets flatter start-ups, and home investors flatter them most of all
At a recent conference, a seasoned entrepreneur of the scale-from-the-start, think-global-from-day-one school offered his audience of young founders a fabulous piece of advice in the form of what was little more than an aside. If you want to test your start-up’s global potential, he said, pitch it as far away from your home market as possible. His argument is based on the idea that raising money at home is, for many founders, sometimes a bit too easy. Local networks are all too willing to help, friends (or friends of friends) are always happy to make an introduction or two and, often, ready to step in with some money, be it seed funding or as part of a Series A round.
There is some decent evidence to suggest that he has a point, although few investors would admit to having been persuaded to part with their cash by anything as unscientific as the old school tie network. Thilo Huning and Fabian Wahl, two economists, went through 13,422 venture deals struck in the German-speaking world between 1999 and 2019 and found that a common regional identity was highly relevant for investment decisions. Researchers at Harvard and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York had a few years previous found that American venture firms earned better returns on start-ups outside their home region than inside it. Distance, it would appear, tends to make investors a bit more careful, or at least a bit less sentimental (and, following the logic to its natural conclusion, more likely to back a winner).
One of the problems (perhaps the key problem) is that catering to local, home markets can do a great deal of damage by designing products and services based exclusively around the tastes of that single domestic market. There’s even a name for it, Galapagos syndrome (allegedly first coined in Japan, not without reason, given that it is home to some textbook cases). Fujitsu for example designed 95 different phones for NTT Docomo, Japan’s biggest mobile operator, between 2001 and 2012, each one produced for Docomo’s own mobile-internet service and to Japanese tastes (one 2014 model offered no fewer than 12 different keypad illumination choices, apparently). Not much of the technology travelled, and you’d be hard pressed to find anyone outside of Japan using a Fujitsu phone today. Even within Japan, Fujitsu handsets (these days produced by Lenovo) are no longer particularly popular. Apple’s iPhone commands more than 50 per cent of the Japanese market.
Of course, Japan is a huge market, and it is perfectly possible to be successful and profitable for a long time without ever expanding beyond borders. But even then, the Fujitsu example demonstrates that a more globally-oriented rival (and few firms are more global than Apple) can always erode market share even at home where a firm might have become far too comfortable. Thinking beyond borders then is not just about expansion abroad, it’s also about protecting that home market that all too often gets taken for granted.
Not that expanding everywhere all at once always delivers (pun intended) great results. Getir, a grocery app founded in Istanbul by Nazım Salur in 2015, is one of the best (or worst, depending on how you look at it) recent examples. Getir made its name by delivering groceries to Istanbul customers in double quick time (no mean feat given that city’s legendary traffic congestion), and, flush with its success during the Covid-19 pandemic decided that it could repeat the trick abroad, expanding into the UK, the Netherlands, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Portugal and the US in 2021. By the end of that year, Getir was operating in 48 cities across eight foreign countries, and investors valued it at 11.8 billion US dollars in March 2022. It did not last. In April 2024, having already left France, Spain, Italy and Portugal, Getir announced that it was quitting the UK, Germany, the Netherlands and America, markets which between them generated just seven per cent of its revenue.
A globally-thinking firm that can adapt to a local market will usually outperform a local firm which can't take its own thinking global.
For anyone who has read research, little of this should come as a surprise. Back in 2011 Startup Genome studied more than 3,200 high-growth technology start-ups and found that 74 per cent of the internet firms that failed did so because they scaled prematurely, hiring and spending before the business underneath was ready to carry the weight. The same report found that start-ups which scale properly typically see growth that’s 20 times faster, attracting more capital and customers. Startup Genome has since found that start-ups with strong connections to the world’s leading tech hubs are 3.25 times more likely to become scale-ups than those without. Read together (and, alas, they seldom are), those two findings suggest that founders should know their potential markets very well before they try to move into any of them.
One of the remarkable things about Japanese phones (and Fujitsu is by no means the only example) is that they were anything but backwards. They were, in many ways, innovative and ground-breaking, not least as Japan was offering a version of the mobile internet in 1999, and phones could be used to pay for things in shops as early as 2004, quite some time before the rest of the world could do the same. The problem was that they were developed for standards (i-mode, and a contactless chip called FeliCa) that very few people outside of Japan ever used, so (much like those Darwinian creatures on the Galapagos) the more advanced they became the less they resembled anything anywhere else. When Apple brought Apple Pay to Japan in 2016 (with the iPhone 7), all it had to do was put FeliCa chips into phones it sold there. The perfect example of a globally-thinking firm that was perfectly happy to adapt to a local market outthinking a local firm which never quite found a way to take its own thinking global.
Nor should Galapagos syndrome be viewed as something only companies are guilty of, as governments can be just as culpable. In 1999 South Korea decided that it would implement a security system that required anyone banking or shopping online to use Microsoft’s Internet Explorer and its ActiveX plug-ins. For years Korea was the only country where online purchases still demanded both, and Lee Seoung-cheol, deputy chairman of the Federation of Korean Industries, took to describing the rules as “Galapagos regulations”. South Korea only killed the rules in 2020.
The lesson, then, is to be ready to be everywhere when the moment is right, rather than to be everywhere prematurely. Markus Villig founded Bolt (as Taxify) in Tallinn in August 2013 at the age of 19, and since Estonia has barely 1.3 million people the app was always going to have to work somewhere else in order to be anything more than a local curiosity. By 2014 it was in Latvia and Lithuania, and when it came to further expansion, rather than pick a fight with Uber (its most entrenched rival) in western Europe or the United States, Villig quite deliberately went where Uber was weaker (or did not exist at all), launching in South Africa in 2016 and in Lagos later that year, as well as in Eastern Europe in 2017.
That, more or less, is what the speaker at the conference was getting at. Pitching far from home is a relatively simple (and cheap, usually requiring little more than the price of a plane ticket) way of finding out whether a business makes sense to people with no parochial or emotional connection, and particular reason to say nice things about it. Some start-ups can (and will) go global from day one, and will be successful. Others will spend years at home first, and for them it will be the right thing to do. What none of them should do, however, is to develop a product or service that only ever makes sense to friends and family.
The byline Reinvantage Insight is used to denote articles to which several members of the Reinvantage insight and analysis team may have contributed.



